All candy is made with the finest ingredients
Featured Products
Candy Girls Key West
Old Fashioned Island Candy
Key West Finest Homemade Candy
Old Fashioned Island Fudge- Plain
15
Using the recipe from the original fudge makers on the island
Old Fashioned Island Fudge - Walnut
15
We added fresh walnuts for a bit of smoky crunch
Old Fashioned Island Fudge - Pecans
15
With the addition of Pecans giving us a taste of Praline
Old Fashioned island Rocky Road Fudge
15
We added marshmallows and Walnut for the ultimate fudge
Old Fashioned Pulled and Glass Candy
We are your local source for this candy from our past
Old Fashioned Island Pulled Peppermint
15
Just like you remember...pulled hot until it reaches that exact sweetness and air. Original Old Fashioned Island Pulled Peppermint!
Old Fashioned Island Strawberry Peppermint
15
Original pulled peppermint with a taste of strawberry
Old Fashioned Island Glass Candy
12
We used the old island recipe and added many new flavors- including Peppermint, Strawberry, Watermelon, Lemon, Orange and our newest flavor, Key Lime
All of our candy is made locally
Candy Girls Key West
$15.00
Old Fashioned Island Candy the way it was made back in the day.